Though both sides of the ball were working just fine for the Oklahoma Sooners against UTEP, it is not controversial at all to claim that both defenses will the the stronger units when the Michigan Wolverines host Brent Venables’ team this Saturday. SP+ has the Sooners’ defense sixth-best after Week 1, and while the metric saw the Michigan offense nearly in-step with the defense in the preseason, the split is now (rightfully) 46th vs. 17th.
The Wolverines certainly struggled against the Oklahoma defense last season, managing a lone touchdown on a Justice Haynes home run immediately after halftime. Meanwhile, the Michigan defense did allow 24 points in Norman, but held Sooner backs to just 57 yards on 19 carries, with quarterback John Mateer the one to find paydirt twice. How the rematch plays out will likely come down to this facet of the game again.
Advertisement
Fact: This is do or die for the offensive line
Preseason analysis is always wrong, but the way the Michigan offensive line played against Western had to be the most concerning miss. Seeing Bryce Underwood continue to struggle is unfortunately not a huge surprise, nor are some questions about defensive tackle depth and linebacker talent. However, for the Wolverine running backs to rush for under 60 yards against a retooling Broncos defensive front was both unacceptable and jarring.
Up next is an actual elite defensive line, filled with experience and multiple preseason All-SEC recognitions. Venables has been known for his dominant fronts, and it was not a fun experience against the Sooners last season. Michigan has the running back talent to still be effective, but the line must play much, much better than in the opener if this game is going to end up any different than the 2025 edition.
Underwood’s inadequacies only rachet up the need for a consistent ground game even more. To me, this contest is going to show exactly how the rest of the season plays out. Yes, the line still has room to get better as time goes on, but if the Wolverines cannot figure out how to lean on the running backs like many of the teams before them, then I am not sure how this offense ever does enough to hang with any decent opponent this season.
Advertisement
Fiction: John Mateer’s legs will be the difference
When I think back to last year’s loss to Oklahoma, all I have in my mind was Mateer running all over everywhere. Indeed, 74 rushing yards is a lot for a quarterback (his second-highest total in 2025), and he scored more touchdowns with his legs than the entire Michigan team combined. It would therefore be foolish to not consider the rushing threat of the Sooners’ quarterback heading into the rematch.
And yet — Mateer did require 19 carries to gain those 74 yards, resulting in a frustrating, but not devastating 3.9 YPC. He absolutely influenced more than the box score showed, forcing the defense to keep eyes on him at all times and bringing defenders into conflict to open up space, but I was a little surprised to see the numbers look a lot more level than how I remembered the narrative.
Mateer is still a weapon, and his legs cannot be ignored at any point. Still, his effectiveness on the ground dwindled after the Michigan game last year, and whether or not that is due to his injury, I would expect the defense to be much more prepared. There are a lot of reasons why the Wolverines may lose this game, but I am going to preach patience before we all collectively claim “mobile quarterback” as the top cause for another defeat.




Comments
Advertisement