Caitlin Clark and Fever now face new expectations after playoff elimination

LAS VEGAS — Around 10 a.m. here on Thursday, the Indiana Fever made their way to the court. A staffer implored everyone to keep it down while the head coach spoke with reporters. It was a nice try. Some players spun a prize wheel stashed in the tunnel. They chittered during pre-shootaround stretches. They clapped while they circled up. A coach had to dance because his last clap came late.

Then Stephanie White, the ringmaster of the WNBA’s biggest circus, spoke to her team. A longer-than-usual monologue, inaudible outside the circle, even in a mostly empty building. For once, the Fever had some quiet. Right in the middle of the Michelob Ultra Arena, hours before another reckoning in a season when those seemed to come by the week.

Advertisement

“WHOOOOOO!” Caitlin Clark exclaimed, pretty much the millisecond her coach finished. “Come on!”

There is always some lightness, if only to counter the occasionally unbearable weight. That set in later. After the blinding start to a decisive Game 3 against the Las Vegas Aces, after the crawl through quicksand for the rest of it, after the bloody lip and a stoic walk off the floor while cannons spit celebratory smoke into the air. After a 94-83 first-round loss that meant the end, and a new beginning for old expectations.

The Indiana Fever and the most famous women’s basketball player on the planet are right there, and also not close. The promise of having a player like Clark to run with fellow All-Stars Aliyah Boston and Kelsey Mitchell is championships. It’s not difficult to confirm. They need only look at the club that’s eliminated them from the last two postseasons.

The Aces are in so many ways who the Fever would like to be. By the end of Thursday, the defending WNBA champions left Clark to check the alignment of her teeth while discussing how Las Vegas put an end to her team’s season, and where she and that team go from here. “We were right there and I felt like we probably played a ‘C’ game,” Clark said. “So it hurts, but a lot to be proud of at the same time.”

Advertisement

As the basketball went, Indiana died by its sword. It scored 31 points in the first quarter. Then Clark went 21-plus minutes without a field goal. Mitchell missed twice as many shots as she made. While Las Vegas star A’ja Wilson stomped on skyscrapers en route to 36 points and 10 rebounds, a fourth-quarter rally by the Fever fell short. One star decided this. She doesn’t play for Indiana.

So, yes, it will always come back to Clark, and all that swirls around the galactic center of this sport, like it or not. Because she can be the difference. She can be the decider.

First year, Clark was a rookie who led her franchise back to the playoffs. That was cool. Last year, she was too hurt to have a say in the postseason. That was unlucky. This year, she produced an MVP-caliber season and then her team drew Godzilla in its first-round matchup. That was unfortunate. This first-round exit, though, was not inevitable. Not after Clark dragged her club through Game 2 and straight into having a real chance against the defending champs.

That was a moment. The bell was rung.

Advertisement

Clark’s timeline has been awash in expectation forever. It will be fully submerged in her fourth year. Playing for everything will be the only thing. “Obviously we live in a world of instant gratification and everybody expects me to win a championship immediately,” Clark said. “And certainly that’s my goal and I think this team has the potential to do that.”

It won’t matter, in these coarse hours after elimination, that doing so depends on variables out of her control.

For example: Clark cannot fill the rotation with more athleticism and better defenders while negotiating the tight corners of the salary cap. Nor can she sign a new contract for Mitchell, who will be an unrestricted free agent after arguably the best season of her professional career. It may soothe Fever fans that Mitchell referred to the franchise as “we” late Thursday night — as in, “All we can do is keep fighting our best to be able to get in these positions” — despite being disconsolate with the result.

“She’s priority No. 1, when you think about the offseason,” White said.

Advertisement

But that is the reason for the urgency from general manager Amber Cox and the rest of the front office. If Mitchell returns to the only WNBA home she’s known, the work of creating an elite core remains well done. When any franchise in any professional league can deploy multiple all-league-level performers, the chances for success are extremely good. The aspirations for championships are concrete. With Boston, Clark and Mitchell, this is base reality for Indiana.

“There’s always going to be room for growth, but with how Amber put this team together, it’s championship or bust,” said forward Myisha Hines-Allen, a veteran of two WNBA Finals and one WNBA title with Washington in 2019. “We have everybody we need in this locker room to get the job done.”

The job did not get done. And puzzling out how to construct a title-winning supporting cast will be complicated.

Assuming Mitchell re-signs for a maximum contract, and assuming Clark inks an EPIC extension like Boston did, the Fever could commit around $4.5 million, give or take, to that group alone. Under the league’s new collective bargaining agreement, the most the current $7 million salary cap can grow for 2027 is 13 percent. Back-of-napkin math reveals Indiana may have 60 percent of its cap devoted to three players.

Advertisement

Stars win, but so does depth of talent. Identifying the right supporting cast for the right price is the trick. Banking on the promise of young talent like Raven Johnson and Mikayla “KK” Timpson is a given, particularly because it’s a relatively cheap investment. But what to do about the combined $1.6 million in protected veteran salary for Monique Billings and Lexie Hull? Hull started 41 games but finished eighth on the team in win shares, while the Fever were 8 points per 100 possessions worse with Billings on the floor.

Then there’s the Sophie Cunningham conundrum. She is wildly popular with Fever fans, has made 42 percent of her 3s across two seasons and, not unimportantly, drives merchandise sales. (At home games, Cunningham’s No. 8 jerseys and T-shirts are prime competition for those bearing Clark’s No. 22.) She is also 30, an unrestricted free agent who posted a minus-6.2 on/off rating in 2026 and she created the loudest distraction to trail the Fever this summer with her comments about transgender athletes.

Predicting where the needle points is pretty simple. Clark has the ball in her hands and the top spot on the marquee. What works best for her, on all fronts, is what works best for the Fever. If Clark believes White is the best coach for this team, by way of example, then White will continue to coach this team. And so on, and so forth.

Had Thursday gone differently, the present and future may have been indistinguishable. It did not. The Fever are in that way like their still-under-construction performance center, an 108,000-square foot edifice they gave a tour of earlier this week. Soon they’ll have a home featuring two full-length courts, a salon, a hydrotherapy room with an underwater treadmill, a patio for outdoor dining and spacious individual “studios” instead of locker room stalls.