Sydney Sweeney hasn’t quite managed to find the same success at the box office as she has on the small screen. Despite acclaimed performances in shows like The White Lotus and Euphoria, Sweeney has had a tough run of appearing in films that underperformed in comparison to expectations. While she’s shown an interest in transforming herself in order to play real people, Sweeney gave her greatest performance to date in an underseen biopic that debuted on HBO. Reality was picked up by HBO Films shortly after its debut at the Berlin Film Festival, and it’s not entirely surprising to see why it skipped theaters; when compared to more straightforward biopics, Reality takes an unconventional approach to replicating recorded conversations.
Reality Winner is a whistleblower from Texas who gained notoriety when she leaked classified documents that indicated Russia was involved in manipulating the 2016 election of President Donald Trump. Although a more straightforward biopic called Winner starring Emilia Jones was released the following year, Reality was a direct adaptation of recorded conversations between Winner and two FBI investigators who arrested her following an intense interrogation. What could have easily been a bland exercise in experimentation turned out to be a gripping modernization of the political thriller genre, and forced Sweeney to completely immerse herself within a controversial figure.
‘Reality’ Has a Unique Docudrama Approach
Reality succeeded by mostly developing its narrative in real time, with only brief introductory and concluding segments used to establish what events led Winner to make her decision. The narrowed perspective of Reality allows the film to focus singularly on the intensity of the moment without suggesting any ulterior motivations or making an abject statement. It’s likely that audiences would already have strong opinions regarding Winner’s actions, and the film doesn’t attempt to present anything about her life that is not on record. Additionally, the narrow focus ensures that Winner is trapped within the intensity of the moment and cannot yet see if her actions have any significant impact on the direction of American politics. Even if she has accepted the consequences that come with the disclosure of critical information, the stakes in Reality feel personal because it’s her specific daily routine that is being disrupted.
Sweeney was put under increased pressure to make adaptive choices given the parameters of her performance; while she had to replicate the exact cadence, accent, and phrasing of the real Winner, she also added a visual component that was consistent with the verbatim dialogue. Reality is a slow burn that shows a young woman gradually realizing the danger she is in, as the conversation with FBI agents Justin C. Garrick (Josh Hamilton) and R. Wallace Taylor (Marchánt Davis) doesn’t feel like the type of overdramatized interrogation that would appear in a spy film. Rather, it’s a deceptively friendly encounter in which the agents present themselves as sympathetic to Winner’s situation whilst making subtle threats and assessing her knowledge of the legal rights. Even though the dialogue isn’t original, Reality finds a way to shape these conversations to hint at the mental game of cat-and-mouse that is going on. There’s also a subtle examination of power dynamics that is conveyed purely through the subtleties within Sweeney’s physical performance; even if what the FBI agents are doing is technically legal, the notion of two older men exercising their authority to intimidate a young woman is disturbing.
‘Reality’ Features Sydney Sweeney’s Most Transformative Performance
Reality achieves a degree of authenticity that is normally reserved for the stage, which makes sense because it was based on a one-act play by the film’s writer/director, Tina Satter. The notably modest production design and stripped-down environments exemplify the mundanity of the situation, which removes any distance that would normally exist in a biopic. Reality examines the deep irony of a complex situation in which public perception of a highly consequential election is determined by a series of awkward encounters between a young woman and two men who stay at her modest home. In fact, Winner’s primary concern at the beginning of the interview seemed to be the safety of her pets, as she may not have considered just how much jail time she could potentially be facing. Reality also functions as a strange coming-of-age story, as it highlights just how young Winner was at the time of her arrest; a woman in her 20s with limited life experience is somehow responsible for revealing an act of corruption that compromises the integrity of America’s institutions.
An argument is often made that a majority of biopics do little more than skim the surface of interesting stories and might function better as a documentary. Reality breaks the biopic mold by finding the drama within undeniable events, forcing viewers to check their biases at the door. It’s a notable departure from the roles that Sweeney has taken in the past, as the strengths of Winner’s convictions are only revealed by the end of the film, in which she is forced to confess her feelings on being referred to as a “whistleblower.” Although Sweeney has made a conscious effort to work with acclaimed auteur filmmakers like Ron Howard and Quentin Tarantino, Reality is an example of her leveraging her star power for the sake of promoting an up-and-coming female filmmaker who has a fresh perspective on the subject material. Despite not making it into theaters, Reality is both proof of Sweeney’s range and the type of experimental historical drama that Hollywood should make more often.
Reality is available to stream on HBO Max in the U.S.




Comments
Advertisement