One of the greatest inherent attributes to comedy as an art form, whether it be through filmmaking, stand-up, or any other method of making audiences laugh, is just how versatile and different each approach to comedy can be. No one has the exact same sense of humor, and what makes one person recoil in disgust may have another laughing so hard that they find themselves on the floor crying. However, certain types of comedy have proven to be more divisive than others, as several films have made names for themselves as being incredibly polarizing and divisive among audiences.
Whether it be because of shocking, risqué comedy or the tackling of taboo subject matter, there has been a vast history of comedy films that have divided audiences. Several of these films have had a wide range of reputations surrounding them, with several being considered all-time comedy classics, while others are considered overwhelming cinematic disasters. However, comedy is always subjective, with each of these films accomplishing something right if they are loved by a subsection of people.
10
‘Sausage Party’ (2016)
Considering just how much the medium of animation as a whole is associated with family filmmaking, Sausage Party, being a raunchy R-rated adult animated comedy with the style and visuals of a family movie, instantly acted as a shock to the system. The film makes a point to shock the audience at every opportunity, whether it be through various stereotypes as food characters, on-screen death and murder, a talking douche, or even an infamous orgy scene at the end.
Like many raunchy comedies before it, the overwhelming reliance on shock humor left audiences and critics alike divided on how to feel about the movie, with some absolutely loving its satirical take on animated films while others found it too crass and repetitive. Even some of the audiences that normally love raunchy humor found the high amounts in Sausage Party too much to handle, reaching a point of ridiculousness, especially with its conclusion. Many critics were more positive towards the film, crediting the originality of its premise and style in an animated format.
9
‘Click’ (2006)
Few comedy stars have been as largely divisive throughout their career as Adam Sandler, with his films either being absolutely loved or hated by audiences, with few falling in between these extremes. One of the most polarizing of his filmography is Click, a film that largely embodies all the conventions and archetypes that have embodied Sandler’s career, both the positive and negative attributes. The film sees Sandler playing a man who makes vast changes to his life after getting a magical TV remote that allows him to control the fabric of life itself, pausing and fast-forwarding through time.
Even among die-hard Sandler fans, Click is largely divisive as some consider it to be one of his absolute best films, while others consider it to be one of his absolute worst. A lot of the discourse surrounds the film’s third act, where the main character goes so far into the future that he sees the folly of his ways as his life has fallen apart. This mixture of harsh philosophical, emotional moments, along with classic raunchy Sandler movie shenanigans, has given the film both many fans and many dedicated haters.
8
‘Mamma Mia!’ (2008)
A rom-com cult classic of the 2000s that has simultaneously delighted and confused audiences ever since its release, Mamma Mia! imbues itself with a distinct tone and style that both amplifies its strengths while alienating select audiences. Musicals as a whole are already a relatively divisive genre, considering how select audiences just can’t connect with the numbers, with Mamma Mia only amplifying this with a soundtrack of entirely ABBA songs.
Critics and audiences who aren’t fans of ABBA’s music have been vocal about their annoyance and dismissal of the film, while dedicated fans have rewatched this film for decades and made it a celebrated cult classic. The interesting dynamic of the film is that even fans are quick to point out the many goofy issues that plague the film, yet these issues only prove to add to the overall charm and fun, making those who love it enjoy the film that much more.
7
‘Napoleon Dynamite’ (2004)
Napoleon Dynamite‘s distinctly dry and dialogue-focused style of slow, awkward humor helped catapult it into being one of the biggest comedy hits of the 2000s, but its stark difference to more traditional comedies also made it wildly divisive. It’s a style of comedy that, while certainly landing for a lot of people, can easily not land with a certain type of audience, simply being so dense and awkward that some may find it either overbearing or simply uninteresting.
It speaks volumes that the film was able to find great success and strike a niche with so many people, as it’s a style of comedy that one wouldn’t particularly expect to resonate with so many people. Jon Heder‘s brilliant performance acts as the perfect encapsulation of this phenomenon, with his awkward, nerdy mannerisms as Napoleon being absolutely hilarious to some and deeply boring to others. There’s a good reason that few other films have been able to replicate the film’s style in the decades since its release.
6
‘The Life of Brian’ (1979)
While modern comedy audiences are much more comfortable with more risqué and controversial material in their comedies, The Life of Brian was released in an era where the concept of a parody of the story of Jesus was seen as blasphemy to some. Even as The Life of Brian has cemented itself as a comedy classic of the ’70s and one of Monty Python’s best films, there are still some who simply can’t find it in themselves to enjoy a film that they see as making a mockery of Christianity.
However, this wasn’t the only hurdle that made the film divisive on release, as Monty Python’s style of goofy, nonsensical humor has made a wide variety of their works divisive over the years. The Life of Brian simply sticks to the style and formula that has made the comedy troupe so legendary, greatly appealing to fans of their witty humor while continuing to alienate those who don’t align with their sense of humor. For the most part, the film has grown beyond its divisive past, yet it’s a prominent aspect of its history as an all-time comedy classic.
5
‘Dogma’ (1999)
Releasing nearly 20 years after Life of Brian, Dogma similarly stirred up a great deal of controversy due to its satirical interpretation of religion, more directly taking jabs at Catholicism as a whole. Its story of two fallen angels attempting to use a loophole in the Catholic dogma to return to Heaven after being cast out by God left several Catholic audiences shocked and appalled, with there being several protests surrounding the film, and the church itself denouncing it as blasphemy.
As for the film itself, it ironically has a varied history of perceived quality among Kevin Smith‘s fans, ranging from those who believe it to be the best film in the View Askewniverse to others believing it to be missing the charm of Smith’s previous films. Even well after the film’s release and controversies died down, its divisive nature always stuck to the film’s legacy, especially when it spent so long not being available to stream or purchase digitally due to rights issues.
4
‘Tropic Thunder’ (2008)
Standing as one of the definitive Hollywood satires of the 21st century, the methods that Tropic Thunder takes to comment and poke fun at the various toxic mentalities and intricacies of film production have made it wildly divisive ever since its release. While Ben Stiller’s previous directorial movies were divisive in their own ways, Tropic Thunder brings it to a new level, with several shocking jokes meant to elicit a reaction while commenting on the pompous mentality of several Hollywood archetypes.
The vast majority of the film’s divisive nature stems from Robert Downey Jr.‘s character of actor Kirk Lazarus, as the method actor character goes to such extreme lengths to get into character that he has surgery done to darken his skin color to give him the appearance of a black man. Reactions surrounding this characterization range from people lambasting the entire movie as a whole and considering it blackface to praising this dark comedic take on the ridiculous lengths of method actors. Even aside from Downey Jr.’s character, Tropic Thunder is filled with wild, extremely hit-or-miss satirical jabs.
3
‘Pink Flamingos’ (1972)
John Waters has made a name for himself by creating some of the most shocking, depraved, yet endlessly endearing dark comedies of all time, with easily his most infamous and notable release being Pink Flamingos. Much like Waters’ other films, Pink Flamingos goes out of its way to shock and discomfort the audience at every opportunity with its distinct blend of dark, shocking humor that was completely unheard of in the ’70s. It’s about as countercultural as a singular film can get, with its constant going against the grain giving it both a myriad of dedicated fans and detractors.
Even over 50 years after the film’s release, the onslaught of shocking and depraved material in Pink Flamingos continues to make the film an icon of poor taste in comedy, with more revolting scenes than one can imagine. Its overwhelming profanity has made it an icon of hatred in the eyes of many, while at the same time giving it a distinct niche and authentic energy that has given it a cult classic status. The film actively relishes being divisive, as at its very core, the film was created to shock and disarm audiences as a tool for its comedy.
2
‘Borat’ (2006)
A timely and provocative mockumentary phenomenon of the 2000s, Borat straddled the line between problematic and brilliant with expert precision, resulting in a final product that is praised as a comedy classic by some and vehemently despised by others. Many different aspects can be attributed to the film’s divisive nature, whether it be the uncomfortable aspects of Sacha Baron Cohen‘s over-the-top performance as Borat, the wide array of shocking, risqué humor, or the real-life exposé elements of its story.
It certainly didn’t help matters that many audiences simply didn’t pick up on the commentary being made in the film, seeing Borat as a goofy caricature that was making fun of Middle Eastern culture with a gross stereotype. The reality is that the film more directly points a finger at the gross mentality of America during this time, with many different elements coming together to make Borat a distinctly more intelligent comedy than people assume. Still, it’s difficult for any film that has such an aggressive political message combined with shocking nudity and gross-out humor to not come out the other end wildly divisive.
1
‘Freddy Got Fingered’ (2003)
The journey and massive shift that Freddy Got Fingered has gone through in the eyes of audience perception is one of the most interesting and individual cases in the world of comedy filmmaking. When the film first came out, it was so massively despised by critics and audiences alike that it was quickly considered to be one of the worst comedies of all time. However, decades of reexamination have been unexpectedly kind to Freddy Got Fingered, as some have found the film to be ingenious in its seemingly purposeful attempts to make the worst comedy possible.
The film sets forth an interesting conundrum in terms of its actual quality that has become the defining point of discussion and divisiveness surrounding the film as a whole. If a film is technically succeeding in its goal of being as terrible as possible, does that make the final product actually good, or still terrible? It certainly makes the film a difficult recommendation for traditional audiences that don’t want to see a man jack off a horse, but for the strangely disturbed and non-traditional audiences, Freddy Got Fingered is a surprising hidden gem.




Comments
Advertisement