Sitcoms rely on standalone storylines, both significant and mundane. As such, audiences have grown accustomed to holiday-themed episodes as a staple of the genre. There is no better plot than a Thanksgiving TV episode. Spending time with family and friends and showing gratitude for the holiday and all its bounty.
This can result in humorous moments that test characters beyond their limits. Or, it can provide lessons in love, family, and healing. It’s also a beacon for mishap and chaos. From Modern Family to Cheers, these beloved shows contain some of the greatest Thanksgiving sitcom episodes of all time.
10
“The Gang Squashes Their Beefs”
‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’ (2005–)
Can The Gang truly make amends for their indiscretions and behaviors? In the spirit of Thanksgiving, The Gang attempts to make amends for all they’ve done to each other over the years. Which would be wholesome, but this is It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia — that’s nearly an impossible task. They even invite those they’ve so terribly wronged over the years, including Cricket (David Hornsby) and the McPoyles.
“The Gang Squashes Their Beefs” alludes to clever commemorations of Thanksgiving traditions, such as peace treaties and welcoming their neighbors. But ultimately, these attempts fail. And in one final act, which proved that The Gang really could not change, they go so far as to trap their guests in a burning room. They may be terrible people, but at least they know it.
9
“Thanksgiving”
‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’ (2013–2021)
Colleagues are more than a team in the 99th Precinct—they are family. As such, it would make sense that their relationships are reminiscent of such. This is evident in Brooklyn Nine-Nine‘s Thanksgiving episodes, which take place each season. But it’s the appropriately titled “Thanksgiving” episode in Season 1 that stands out as the greatest.
Amy (Melissa Fumero) takes on the role of host at a dinner party that quickly descends into chaos. For one, she can’t cook very well, which deters the group. Additionally, Jake (Andy Samberg) must confront past trauma around the holiday to join in the festivities. And in a sudden B-plot, a robbery occurs that needs attention. Much like other sitcoms, a dinner party sets the stage for cringe entertainment that you don’t want to look away from. It may be unfortunate for the characters, but it is always hilarious for viewers.
8
“Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations”
When Shirley (Yvette Nicole Brown) invites the study group for Thanksgiving dinner, things go awry. Abed (Dani Pudi) helms the escape plan, so, naturally, it resembles a scheme from some movie. In this case, they treat the escape like that found in The Shawshank Redemption. Meanwhile, Jeff (Joel McHale) must confront his familial history when he meets his absent father and unknowing stepbrother, and make peace with his past.
By now, the study group resembles a family. “Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations” is a masterpiece of reckoning and reconciliation, told through two diverging plotlines. As with most episodes of Community, this episode features themes and moments that pay homage to pop culture. Sure, it’s dark and even emotional. But in many ways, wholesome as the study group comes together for a holiday meant for loved ones.
7
“Blitzgiving”
‘How I Met Your Mother’ (2005–2014)
By Season 6 of How I Met Your Mother, Ted (Josh Radnor) and his friends have begun to figure out their lives. This leaves room for new adventures and symbolizes growth in their values and connections with one another. However, that does not mean they are done learning.
Ted faces this the hard way when, instead of preparing to host his first Thanksgiving dinner, he experiences what is described as “The Curse of Blitzgiving.” When Ted makes the mature decision to leave the bar at an acceptable hour before his friends, he is met with severe FOMO the following day. Or, “The Curse of the Blitz,” in which a person “always leaves the group before something epic happens.” It’s just one of many How I Met Your Mother Thanksgiving episodes, but it’s also the best.
6
“The Miracle of Thanksgiving”
‘Full House’ (1987–1995)
It’s the Tanner family’s first Thanksgiving without their matriarch, and spirits are low. Danny (Bob Saget) strives to make it the best holiday for his girls. But when Danny’s mother can’t make it in time and no one is there to cook dinner, the household is thrown into panic. After a series of mishaps — D.J.’s (Candace Cameron-Bure) failed attempts at cooking — it’s clear that they are still learning to live life without Pam. And that’s okay.
Something that Full House always did well was balancing humor with more serious topics. Danny, Joey (David Coulier), and Jesse (John Stamos) sought to make the girls’ childhood as engaging as possible under the circumstances. So, while this proved challenging at times, it meant creative measures had to be taken. Thanksgiving is a day to be with family, and “The Miracle of Thanksgiving” proved that everyone living in the Tanner household was forming a new kind of family.
5
“Bart vs. Thanksgiving”
‘The Simpsons’ (1989–)
The Simpsons has only a handful of Thanksgiving-centric episodes, which is surprising considering the show’s 37 seasons. But it’s “Bart vs. Thanksgiving” that takes the cake (turkey?). It all begins with a centerpiece Lisa (Yeardley Smith) makes for the Simpsons’ Thanksgiving dinner table, which leads Bart (Nancy Cartwright) to run away from home. The episode gets dark from there, but it’s still infused with the humor fans expect, even early in the long-running series.
The Simpsons are meant to represent your average family, and “Bart vs. Thanksgiving” does just that—both the good and the bad. The episode also addressed existing social issues, such as homelessness. And, as is customary with much of The Simpsons, it offered clever pop culture references in various ways. The payoff was worth it, as more than 11 million viewers tuned in that week.
4
“Thanksgiving”
‘New Girl’ (2011–2018)
Aptly titled “Thanksgiving,” New Girl‘s Season 1 is the first of many holiday episodes of the series. Jess (Zooey Deschanel) is still early in her time among the boys and is actively trying to make a good impression on them. Thanksgiving is the test. Jess must make up for forgetting to defrost a turkey while still impressing her crush, Paul (Justin Long).
There are also brief moments of forbidden chemistry between Jess and Nick (Jake Johnson), whose relationship would eventually develop into a slow-burning romance for the ages. But for now, early in Season 1, Nick can only sit back and watch as Jess and her latest man hit it off right before his eyes. This Season 1 holiday episode is fairly uniform, but it features elements we love from a good sitcom, including disastrous turkey debacles, a chaotic dinner, and, specifically to New Girl, Jess donning a wacky turkey costume.
3
“Three Turkeys”
‘Modern Family’ (2009–2020)
Each branch of the Pritchett-Dunphy family has something to hide, making for hilarious misunderstandings. Claire (Julie Bowen) hides a second turkey from Phil (Ty Burrell) and Luke (Nolan Gould), whom she doesn’t trust to cook it properly. Meanwhile, Jay (Ed O’Neill) and Gloria (Sofía Vergara) must hide from the family when their vacation plans are cancelled. As for Mitch (Jesse Tyler Ferguson) and Cam (Eric Stonestreet), they must work with Lily (Aubrey Anderson-Lemmons) to get her to wear a dress to dinner, going so far as to do the same in solidarity.
The extended family is up to their typical antics, and as usual, the writing is tight with each intersecting plot. As with many sitcoms, each season tends to feature major events and holidays that happen each year. Modern Family does this well on every occasion, including Halloween and Christmas. But there is nothing like a dysfunctional family taking on Thanksgiving, and the Pritchetts-Dunphys embody this perfectly.
2
“The One with All the Thanksgivings”
‘Friends’ (1994–2004)
“The One with All the Thanksgivings” takes an inventive stance, approaching the holiday in a more nostalgic light. That is, a series of flashbacks consisting of the friend group’s best (and worst) Thanksgiving moments. Including one memorable time in which Monica (Courteney Cox), in all her glory, somehow manages to get a turkey stuck on his head.
Friends has notoriously produced many Thanksgiving episodes throughout its ten-season run, and they remain relevant even today. It truly conveys the concept of “Friendsgiving.” Thus, choosing the very best proves challenging. Yet, “The One with All the Thanksgivings” stands out amongst the rest for its method of storytelling and originality. However, honorable mentions must be given out to “The One with the Rumor” and “The One Where Ross Got High.”
1
“Thanksgiving Orphans”
‘Cheers’ (1982–1993)
“Thanksgiving Orphans” is highly regarded as one of the greatest Thanksgiving episodes of Cheers—and of sitcoms as a whole. The title is appropriate, as everyone in the bar is, essentially, alone during the holiday. That’s when Carla (Rhea Perlman) invites everyone into her home to enjoy a Thanksgiving meal together. Taking this group of misfits outside the bar would eventually lead to disaster.
Slowly, tensions rise between everyone until, eventually, a wild food fight breaks out and all goes to chaos. And it’s epic. TV Guide ranked it number seven on its list of the greatest episodes of all time. It’s one of the few times that Cheers is set outside the bar, allowing for new plots to unfold. Additionally, “Thanksgiving Orphans” received an impressive 8.6 stars on IMDb.




Comments
Advertisement