When best friends since High School Montell, Eric and Manny, all think they’ve got their lives figured out, they suddenly realize life is about to get a lot more complicated when Sherri, a woman that they all had a relationship with at the same time without knowing, after running into her at their High School Reunion, suddenly drops a newborn baby at Montell’s doorstep with a note that say’s “One of you is the daddy”. Now the three friends have to figure out who the baby’s daddy is, all while trying their best to raise the kid, when another bomb is dropped on them, when Eric’s nephew DJ Jukebox reveals he also slept with Sherri as well at the High School Reunion. Now all 4 men must figure out who’s the Daddy?